User reviews

User Review - Flag as inappropriate

on page 542 is a error of names n generations. not sure if will reach editors and record keepers lol but many get it wrong . decent book though but many get facts wrongs . read below hope explains bit .John Ellis Redcloud was Dewitt Clinton Duncan nephew from his brother Walter Adair Duncan who was named after Walter n Clinton father John Duncan . it is worth noting john ellis redcloud also had a son named after none else then his uncle Dewitt Clinton Duncan lol was born on 24 May 1912 in Tahlequah,Okla.. He died on 18 Oct 1991 in Claremore,Roger Co.Okla
book list that DeWitt Clinton Duncan aka Too Qua Stee was born to John Ellis Redcloud Duncan and his wife Elizabeth Aercrombie Duncan ... ellis was her grand son ..
John Duncan is not the same John Ellis Redcloud Duncan Birth: Mar. 26, 1860 Death: Jul., 1947 ..
John [ER] Duncan married Susan "Susie" Elizabeth Carselowey .
thus you listed wrong John Duncan as Redcloud was not DWC's father . as red cloud was born after Dewitt Clinton Duncan aka Too Qua Stee....
oops lol need to check dates next time is confusing
re : John Ellis red-cloud Duncan Birth: Mar. 26, 1860 Death: Jul., 1947
re: Dewitt Clinton Duncan 1829-1907
De Witt Clinton Duncan's father was John Duncan b1785-d1850 who married Elizabeth Abercrombie b1794-d1848 .
Dewitt Clinton Duncan 1829-1907 can be found on 1851 Old Settlers Roll: Tahlequah, Group 91.Old Settlers Roll 1894-1896: Page 14. Dawes Roll # 33135, roll# 7752. 1902-1907.
John Duncan was a Judge of Hickory Log District in 1826-8. He represented the same district in the convention that adopted the Constitution of July 26, 1827. He was appointed to the Committee on June 26, 1840. He died in 1850. His wife, Elizabeth nee Abercrombie, was a native of Tennessee. She died in 1848. his children Walter n Dewitt Clinton served for the Cherokee public service.
john was son of Charles Gordon Duncan 1750-1817 and Dorcas [Benge lightfoot] Duncan 1760-1836

All reviews - 1
5 stars - 0
4 stars - 0
3 stars - 0
2 stars - 0
1 star - 0

All reviews - 1
Editorial reviews - 0

All reviews - 1